Your report says Balkan, and your family says Croatian. Both are true, and neither tells you what you most want to know. Balkan DNA results describe a region of origin shared by many countries, and the studies of the region’s populations explain why the numbers for Croatia, Serbia and Bosnia look so alike. This guide explains what the Balkan label covers, what published research says about how close Croatians are to their neighbors, what a major 2023 study found about the Slavic-speaking migrations, how to read small percentages and where island and coastal families differ. It draws on a company’s own country pages, population-genetics studies and a review of Croatian heritage, as of October 2026.
What the Balkan label covers
MyHeritage reports a Balkan ethnicity, and its own pages on ethnicity by country, which are labeled beta, give the share of its users in each country who have it: 92.3 percent in Croatia, 95.7 in Serbia, 95.1 in North Macedonia and 92.6 in Bosnia and Herzegovina, in a snapshot that is undated. 23andMe’s reference-population page lists a Bosnian, Croatian, Montenegrin and Serbian population inside a Greek and Balkan group. A DNA-education blog says several of the major companies report a Balkan region. The common thread is that a Balkan result tells you the region, and the company’s table shows how widely it is shared. A Croatian family should expect Balkan to be the headline, and Croatia to be the least informative way to read it.
Why neighbors look so similar
| Finding | Source |
|---|---|
| The genetic variation of Western Balkan populations reveals continuity between the Middle East and Europe via the Balkan region, and the region was one of the major routes of ancient gene flow | A study of the genetic structure of Western Balkan populations |
| The lowest genetic diversity was found between the Croatian population and the neighboring population of Bosnia and Herzegovina, and the Croatian population shows a high degree of homogeneity | A review chapter on Croatian genetic heritage, based on 507 Y-chromosome haplotypes |
| Certain genetic similarities were observed between the Pula and Varaždin subpopulations and some neighboring countries | The same review chapter |
| Balkan populations share a common ancestry without major genetic barriers | A review of Y-chromosome haplogroup frequencies in the Balkans |
For a family historian, these findings explain why a company that does not isolate Croatia is not necessarily making an error. The populations are close, and the borders drawn in the twentieth century cut across a genetic neighborhood, much as our regions and ruling states guide shows for the records.
DNA test
Ready to try a MyHeritage DNA test?
See what a MyHeritage DNA test includes, from ethnicity estimates to DNA matches with relatives who have tested too.
The Slavic migrations in the data
A 2023 study in the journal Cell reconstructed a genetic history of the Balkans from the Roman frontier to the Slavic migrations. Its abstract says that people of Eastern European Slavic-speaking populations contributed 30 to 60 percent of the ancestry of Balkan people. It also reports that migrants from central and northern Europe and the steppe arrived between about 250 and 550 CE, and that a large-scale influx of people of Anatolian ancestry occurred in the Imperial period. A review chapter on Croatian heritage adds a different framing from male lineages, saying that a substantial majority, exceeding three quarters of the present-day Croatian male population, likely traces its ancestry to Old Europeans who survived the last glacial maximum in European refuges. The two statements measure different things and should not be set against each other. Neither tells you where your family lived in 1800.
Reading small percentages
- Treat a trace as a clue. A small percentage of a neighboring region may reflect the closeness of the populations, an estimate at the edge of the method or a real ancestor. Only a document or a relative can tell which.
- Expect estimates to change. Companies revise their reference groups and regions, so a figure may move after an update, as our guide to choosing a test cautions.
- Do not translate percentages into generations. A simple rule of doubling a percentage for each generation back is rough at best.
- Compare across companies carefully. Each company has its own regions, so Balkan at one is not the same box as Bosnian, Croatian, Montenegrin and Serbian at another.
Dalmatia, Slavonia and the islands differ
Studies sampled by region show that Croatians are not uniform, even if they are homogeneous overall. A study of 518 men found haplogroup I2a at 52.88 percent in Hvar, 50.48 percent in Split, 40.91 percent in Osijek and 31.31 percent in Pula, with a second group varying by place, as our Y-DNA and mtDNA guide explains. Island populations show strong drift. A review of mitochondrial DNA says haplogroups I and W were elevated on Krk, HV on Brač, J on Hvar and H on Korčula, and that the high degree of endogamy and isolation explains it. A family from those islands may therefore have a result that looks different from an inland family’s even without any recent outside ancestry.
Italian, Venetian and other layers
Coastal Croatia had Venetian and Italian rule, as our guide to Dalmatia and Istria explains. A name or a record may be Italian without the ancestor having been. The studies we read describe Croatian populations as part of a regional genetic landscape and do not give a separate Italian component, so a small Italian or Southern European estimate should be read with the same caution as any trace, and checked against the paper trail.
Free trial
Ready to put your research into a family tree?
Start a free MyHeritage trial to build your tree online and search historical records and other family trees as you add each generation.
A worked example, invented for illustration
Example (invented, for illustration only): A reader’s report shows a high Balkan percentage and a small amount of an Italian region. Her family is from an Istrian village and her great-grandfather’s surname was Italianized in the 1930s. She notes that Balkan is shared by neighboring countries and that Istria had Italian rule, then checks the parish registers for the original form of the surname, using our guide to the 1926 decrees. The record shows a Croatian -ić surname. The DNA estimate had only raised the question, and the register answered it.
What we could not verify
- How accurately each company separates Croatia from Bosnia and Serbia.
- Current percentages on any company’s pages, since the MyHeritage snapshot is undated.
- How each company defines its Balkan region.
- Whether regional differences inside Croatia are large enough to show up in a commercial report.
Sources include 23andMe’s page on reference populations, a blog on Balkan DNA ethnicity, a study of Western Balkan populations, a review chapter on Croatian genetic heritage, a review of Balkan Y-chromosome haplogroup frequencies, the 2023 Cell study of the Balkans, a study of Croatian Y-chromosome heritage and a review of Croatian mtDNA and Y-chromosome lineages. The MyHeritage figures come from its own ethnicity-by-country pages, which we cite in text and do not link.
More guides are in Genetic Genealogy, and the DNA hub gives an overview.
Disclosure: Croatian Roots may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Our affiliate disclosure explains how we handle that.